Peer-Review Assignment #1

-
This first peer-review looks at Geoprocessing tool to model beach erosion due to storms: application toFaro beach (Portugal).

The paper is on a geoprocessing tool used to model beach erosion, specifically applied to Faro beach in South Portugal. This tool would assess beach erosion due to storms using two computational modules in order to determine whether the geoprocessing tool would be useful in helping predict storm impact along Faro beach. Its final conclusion was that the tool does work after several testing procedures to assure that the tool could be relied upon.
It appears to be original work published on the Journal of Coastal Research, Special Issue 64, 2011 by faculty from Center for Marine and Environmental Research (CIMA) at Algarve University and University of Lisbon in Portugal.
The science and testing procedures described were clear and concise. Sufficient data information is provided to follow along their methods of testing the geoprocessing tool. The paper appears to have been published at least one year after the most recent data examined in the paper. I would want to follow up with the team to provide more recent data and discuss the tool’s effectiveness in recent years.
I can’t think of anything to add to this brief yet highly informative paper on a tool. They did a great job in communicating what its purpose is, what their goal was and how they hoped to use the tool long term, data sets were provided along with clear walkthroughs of how they employed test procedures, walkthroughs for the modules used are also provided so the reader gains an understanding of the inner workings of the tool and what it’s supposed to produce in the final outcome. Images of data and maps to follow along were also provided to have a better visual of what the projected data looked like. A full bibliography is also provide for further reading.
The strongest points were presentation and flow. It’s obvious that one would need to be highly familiar with a lot of the terminology and applications described in order to fully comprehend and appreciate the work one here. But someone less savvy on the subject matter could manage to understand what this paper aims to achieve through the use of a concise written abstract, conclusions, and maps. For weaknesses, the paper would benefit from  including a more recent data set would be good to review the tool’s reliability and some counter arguments detailing past tried and failed test cases to grasp the accuracy of the modules used.
Upon further consideration, it’s definitely a work worth publishing as it goes into sufficient depth of a modeling tool that could help coastal areas with human occupation be adequately prepared for storms in the future.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Module 6- Proportional Bivariate

-
Image
This last module dealt with proportional bivariate mapping methods. Below is a proportional map reflecting negative and positive values for the increase and decrease in the number of jobs across the U.S. We had to convert the negative values into positive values for this purpose, which allowed to symbolize is proportional to the positive values for comparison. I selected a light bright blue hue to represent the loss of jobs and a warmer purple hue to represent jobs gained. For this particular symbology need, the challenge was not so much the quantity of the values I wanted to communicate. The challenge was finding a balance and gain a better understanding of how to use color themes for that purpose. Initially, I had considered using red and blue (as in hot and cold), but it felt too political and not related to the subject matter. The main exercise for this module demanded that we create a bivariate map displaying the relationship between obesity and physical inactivity perc
Read more

Module 4- Color Choropleth

-
Image
This week's module dealt with Choropleth mapping and color theory. Not being an artist, this was somewhat intense and thought-provoking. Our lab was great in walking you through the process of selecting the right color theme for a map. First, we covered some exercises in color ramp progressions. Below is an example displaying three varying gradients using the same base dark green hue. Original intervals: 51, 26, 31. In the Adjusted Progression, I reduced the previous intervals by -10 and added the values to each new set of RGB values. This appeared to make the hues above a shade darker. The adjusted progression is noticeably a shade darker in hue than both linear progression and ColorBrewer. ColorBrewer is also slightly more green, you can notice this change on the lightest color. I’m unsure what the formula used to produce those hues is, but they exhibit a bit more saturation within the hue. For the main lab exercise, we had to create a map displaying the change in the cou
Read more

GIS5100 Week10: Final Project

-
Image
My final project was dedicated to finding suitable areas for a new Elementary School site in Riverside County, California. I started out by compiling 5 pieces of key datasets: County Assessor parcel data, California Schools, Fault zones, Roads, and Public sites. First I performed euclidean distance analyses on four of them in order to produce zonal raster for preferred areas. A weighted analysis based on prioritizing safety shows that ideal areas fall within Hemet, Menifee, and Palm Springs Unified School Districts. Final analysis results show how active school sites are distributed, where all vacant parcels of at least 5 Acres or more lie, and recommended areas for a new school site. The two circled were determined to be the most suitable after analyzing results from weighted overlay analyses and locations of parcels. Additional setbacks are anticipated as more conditions are implemented to the list of mandatory criteria needed to finalize parcels. Looking b
Read more